Kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip. Philip Stratton 2019-02-16

Kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip Rating: 5,3/10 1724 reviews

9780415335577

kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip

I outline how these duties are to be understood and show how they offer a plausible and elegant connection between the reason why we ought to do certain acts, the normative reasons we have to do these acts, the reason why moral agents will do them, and the reasons certain people have to resent someone who does not do them. I then argue that this form of deontology makes it harder to unify a pluralistic ethics under a single consequentialist principle in a plausible way, and illustrate this with reference to Rob Shavers consequentialist arguments. This eliminativism involves what I call an ontological claim, the claim that there is no real property of goodness, and an error theory, the claim that all value talk is false. But their cases remind us that there is no clear cut-off point between intuitionism and other schools of moral thought. Review: 'A sure-footed and elegant argument. I reject the standard account of self-evidence on the basis that an understanding of a proposition cannot provide a justification for believing that proposition. I argue that, even if we accept N , this conclusion does not follow.

Next

9780415335577

kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip

Filling out the details: Ross's theory of prima facie duties. A bowl of ice cream tastes wonderful, and one can derive great pleasure from eating it, but it is entirely inappropriate to say that ice cream is therefore morally good, or that the person who eats it or who serves it up is morally good; one cannot say that eating or serving ice cream is the moral thing to do. In this paper I argue that the best form of deontology is one understood in terms of prima facie duties. Thus a Kantian account of moral worth is one where the virtuous agent may be responsive to concrete particular considerations, whilst preserving an essential role for universal moral principles. On the value of acting out of duty.

Next

Kant, duty, and moral worth (Book, 2000) [automatictrade.net]

kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip

Kant's theory of moral worth involves identifying the individual as the author of moral law. Philip Stratton-Lake offers a unique account of acting from duty, which utilizes the distinction between primary and secondary motives. Philip Stratton-Lake offers a unique account of acting from duty which utilises the distinction between primary and secondary motives. Kant, Duty and Moral Worth is a lucid examination of Kant's moral thought that will appeal to Kant scholars and anyone interested in moral theory. Normative properties could only be descriptive properties if there is some descriptive way in which all instances of normative properties are similar.

Next

Philip Stratton

kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip

Kant, Duty and Moral Worth is a lucid examination of Kant's moral thought that will appeal to Kant scholars and anyone interested in moral theory. Whether or not one is sympathetic to his moral theory, one cannot ignore it, or the various ethical theories which draw their inspiration from it. He maintains that the moral law should not be understood as a normative moral reason but as playing a transcendental role. Kant, Duty and Moral Worth is a lucid examination of Kant's moral thought that will appeal to Kant scholars and anyone interested in moral theory. Respect and moral motivation: Introduction; Kant's different claims about respect; Respect as a complex state; Moral feeling as the way in which we are conscious of the moral law; The role of the moral law; Moral motivation and internalism. Reviews 'A sure-footed and elegant argument.

Next

Kant, Duty and Moral Worth by Philip Stratton

kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip

He maintains that the moral law should not be understood as a normative moral reason but as playing a transcendental role. He maintains that the moral law should not be understood as a normative moral reason but as playing a transcendental role. His first argument is based on the principle that necessarily coextensive predicates ascribe the same property N , and the claim that there is a descriptive predicate that is necessarily coextensive with normative predicates. Philip Stratton-Lake offers a unique account of acting from duty, which utilizes the distinction between primary and secondary motives. Conclusion: Absolutely universal principles and context sensitivity Author s Bio Philip Stratton-Lake is senior lecturer in Philosophy at the University of Reading. Kant, Duty and Moral Worth is a fascinating and original examination of Kant's account of moral worth.

Next

Kant, Duty and Moral Worth

kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip

Thus a Kantian account of moral worth is one where the virtuous agent may be responsive to concrete particular considerations, whilst preserving an essential role for universal moral principles. Ross's classic of 20th Century philosophy The Right and the Good Clarendon, 2002 ; and On What We Owe to Each Other Blackwell, forthcoming. Thus a Kantian account of moral worth is one where the virtuous agent may be responsive to concrete particular considerations, whilst preserving an essential role for universal moral principles. The complex debate at the heart of Kant's philosophy is over whether Kant said moral actions have worth only if they are carried out from duty, or whether actions carried out from mixed motives can be good. However, his most significant contribution to moral philosophy is his concept of a prima facie duty, which A. Kant would say that the agent cannot control anything other than his own actions - I can only jump in the water and swim out to the drowning person and bring them back to shore. Thus a Kantian account of moral worth is one where the virtuous agent may be responsive to concrete particular considerations, whilst preserving an essential role for universal moral principles.

Next

Kant, duty, and moral worth (Book, 2000) [automatictrade.net]

kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip

He is the editor of Ethical Intuitionism: Re-evaluations Clarendon, 2002 ; the new edition of W. In this chapter the notion of a derivative prima facie duty is considered. In particular they both endorse the intuitionist epistemology according to which basic moral truths are self-evident, and the non-naturalist moral realism that is distinctive of ethical intuitionists. Philip Stratton-Lake offers a unique account of acting from duty, which utilizes the distinction between primary and secondary motives. He maintains that the moral law should not be understood as a normative moral reason but as playing a transcendental role.

Next

9780415335577

kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip

Regarding Scanlon's two arguments, the authors find that the parsimony argument, once clarified, does offer some support for the buck-passing view, but that the appeal to value pluralism does not. Doing the right thing just because it is right. He maintains that the moral law should not be understood as a normative moral reason but as playing a transcendental role. He maintains that the moral law should not be understood as a normative moral reason but as playing a transcendental role. Finally, they defend Scanlon's account against an 'open question' worry about the relation between the fact that something has reason-giving properties and its goodness. He maintains that the moral law should not be understood as a normative moral reason but as playing a transcendental role. You can't have done it for fame and glory, for pecuniary reward, or whatever, as those things are not moral not that they are immoral, but that they have no moral value.

Next

What is the importance of Kant's theory on moral worth?

kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip

An eliminatitivist understanding of derivative prima facie is defended, according to which basic duties do not ground distinct derivative duties, but replace eliminate them. Conclusion: Absolutely universal principles and context sensitivity About the Author Philip Stratton-Lake is senior lecturer in Philosophy at the University of Reading. Review 'A sure-footed and elegant argument. He is the editor of Ethical Intuitionism: Re-evaluations Clarendon, 2002 ; the new edition of W. Ethical intuitionism is a movement in ethics that dates back to the early eighteenth century.

Next

What is the importance of Kant's theory on moral worth?

kant duty and moral worth stratton lake philip

Ross's classic of 20th Century philosophy The Right and the Good Clarendon, 2002 ; and On What We Owe to Each Other Blackwell, forthcoming. On the eliminativist view, discovering that a prima facie duty is derivative is discovering that it is not genuine. Doing the right thing just because it is right. This is because they were both consequentialists, and so denied the view held by most intuitionists that there is an irreducible number of basic moral principles. His second argument rests on the premise that the nature of normative properties cannot depend on which first order normative theory is true. The debate over whether or not Kant said moral actions have worth only if they are carried out from duty or whether actions carried out from mixed motives can be good is complex and lies at the heart of Kant's philosophy. Kant, Duty and Moral Worth is a lucid examination of Kant's moral thought that will appeal to Kant scholars and anyone interested in moral theory.

Next